Citing historic drought, governors are latest to ask EPA to waive corn-ethanol mandate

WASHINGTON, D.C. – August 15, 2012 – In separate letters sent yesterday, Governor Beverly Perdue (D-NC) and Governor Mike Beebe (D-AR) officially petitioned the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to grant a waiver from the ethanol quotas mandated by the federal Renewable Fuels Standard (RFS). 

“It is now beyond dispute that our nation is undergoing a severe, prolonged drought that is of historic proportions and is causing widespread damage to many of the most productive agricultural regions in the country,” Governor Perdue noted in her petition.  The direct harm, she added, was “caused by the RFS requirement to utilize ever-increasing amounts of corn and soybeans for transportation fuel.  Whatever the final damage done by the severe lack of rainfall, it is clear that this harm is reflected in accelerated prices for corn and soybeans, which have a severe economic impact on the state of North Carolina, various regions within the state, and important economic sectors within the state.”

“While the drought may have triggered the price spike in corn, an underlying cause is the federal policy mandating ever-increasing amounts of corn for fuel,” Governor Beebe said in his petition.  “The higher feed costs following the passage of RFS1 in 2005 and RFS2 in 2007 have resulted in a long-term shortage of grain in our nation, especially corn, and are clearly taking a terrible toll on Arkansas’ poultry and animal agriculture, potentially forcing reduced production and job losses and increasing food prices for consumers worldwide… I urge you to begin a formal process for considering a waiver of the renewable fuel mandate,” Beebe concluded. 

Arkansas and North Carolina are the second and fourth largest broiler chicken producing states, respectively.  For turkey production, North Carolina ranks second and Arkansas third nationally. 

The National Chicken Council and National Turkey Federation offered strong support for the petitions requesting an immediate RFS waiver and lauded Governors Perdue and Beebe for their leadership.

“On behalf of North Carolina’s and Arkansas’s chicken farmers and processors, and the entire chicken industry, I thank Governors Perdue and Beebe for their efforts in trying to bring some relief to poultry producers, consumers and the economic sectors that are struggling due to the drought, the high price of corn and continued corn-ethanol mandates,” said National Chicken Council President Mike Brown.  “I strongly urge EPA Administrator Jackson to immediately grant a full, one-year waiver for the corn-ethanol mandate.” 

“As this drought continues to wreak havoc on our nation’s corn crops, we are grateful to Governors Perdue and Beebe who are showing real leadership by asking for relief,” said Joel Brandenberger, president of National Turkey Federation.  “We need a waiver now, while EPA has the ability to make a difference in our members’ livelihoods and the nation’s economy.  These governors are asking for the right thing- at a time when it is critical and we thank them.”

The governors’ petitions come on the heels of last Friday’s World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates (WASDE) report, in which the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) slashed its estimate for the 2012-13 corn crop.  USDA forecasted the 2012-13 corn crop to be 10.8 billion bushels with a yield of 123.4 bushels per acre, down more than 22 bushels per acre from the last estimate.  This severely reduced  corn supply will result in 533 million bushels fewer than the previous estimates , an ending carry-over inventory of corn for the 2012-13 crop year of 650 million bushels, or 5.8 percent of total corn usage .  It would be the smallest carry-over since 1995-96 crop year.  USDA also forecasts record high corn prices of $7.50 to $8.90 per bushel at the farm level, which could be more than 40 percent higher than the 2011-12 crop year.  Further, USDA reduced its feed usage forecast from its report last month by over 15 percent; much of this short corn crop’s burden will fall heavily on poultry and livestock producers.

Governors Perdue and Beebe join a long list of recent requests to waive the RFS, including calls from 156 U.S. House members, 26 U.S Senators, poultry and livestock producers, the United Nations, Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley and Delaware Governor Jack Markell.